Vital Choice Wild Seafood & Organics

Food Industry and Retail
badge Company profile claimed
889 reviews
Overall Rating
Customer Reviews about

Vital Choice Wild Seafood & Organics

Write a review about vitalchoice.com
Show Reviews

Brian

2.00/5.00

"Since 1-800 1Flowers Acquired Vital Choice..."

Since Vital Choice was acquired by 1-800-Flowers there has been a noticeable decline in product quality.
"Fresh fish should not smell Fishy." Never did until the company was sold.
Our most recent shipment contained a package where the vacuum seal is broken.
When ordering our usual quantity of salmon we used to receive 0ne box for the shipment, now $ boxes for the same quantity.

18/11/2023

Denise Dollard

1.00/5.00

"Wish that I could give zero stars"

Wish that I could give zero stars! It is so sad to me that Vital Choice has sold out to a big corporate entity and is no longer the well run, small supplier of seafood that it used to be. We were regular customers. The quality is terrible and the customer service is even worse! I will now by my seafood from Northwest Wild Foods who provide reliably excellent quality and excellent customer service. The fish I ordered from Vital Choice arrived completely thawed, which was the first nightmare. The second one was trying to communicate with customer service. The person did not speak English, and was in a room full of other loud customer service agents on the phone, making it even more impossible to hear or understand her.

03/10/2023

TheTraveler

2.00/5.00

"Quality has gone downhill"

I’ve been ordering from vitachoice for quite a few years but I noticed the salmon are now various sizes and cuts not uniform at all. Some of my boxes have odd shapes and lots of tails, even the copper river king.
One box of Chilean sea bass had some other type of fish mixed in! Granted they replaced the order but it’s become a hassle and I never know what I’m really going to get.
I plan to order my salmon and sea bass from someone else. Very disappointed in what used to be a very reliable source of seafood!

03/10/2023

Dean Bailiff

1.00/5.00

"I purchased the King salmon and the…"

I purchased the King salmon and the copper river salmon, both expensive and marketed as the best salmon. Maybe my experience was not normal, given the reviews, but what I received was a bunch of odd pieces that looked like an inexperience beginner hacked off some salmon fillets all of difference sizes and shapes. Nothing like nice select cuts you would expect for the high price (and pictured). Plus, the taste was not the best. Based on what I had, I prefer what I get from my local grocery store and Walmart, better flavors and fat content, and of course a lot cheaper.

12/09/2023

GiGi

5.00/5.00

"The Chilean Seabass & Sablefish are MUST BUYS!"

Come to Vital Choice Seafood for their:
- Sablefish
- Chilean Seabass
- Canned Sardines (in EVOO)
- Canned Mackerel (in EVOO)

Some of the BEST I have ever had!

14/04/2023

T. in OR

1.00/5.00

"Worst possible business practices"

Worst possible business practices. I had purchased seafood from Vital Choice in the past and loved the quality of the food, especially the sable, and the courteous services rendered, but once Vital Choice was purchased by another company and became part of a big conglomerate, the chaos began. For me, the bad experiences began with lost orders, missing orders, bad communications, thawed fish, etc so I cancelled my membership promptly. (I cancelled the extra cost subscription status they call PASSPORT). This was six months ago. I have never ordered from this company again. To my chagrin, late last night, Vital Choice ran my credit card and renewed my membership "as if" I hadn't already cancelled it last year. So I called them first thing this morning to complain and to insist upon immediate rectification and credit. The company shows itself to be located in Oregon but their calling is outsourced to a foreign country and after being required to give them personal information up front, it took a long time for the voice on the other end to say that they weren't allowed to help, and couldn't assure cancellation, they had to put me on hold and transfer me to another location, at which point I had to begin the time consuming process all over again. The people who staff the phones provide their first name only, and provide that with great reluctance. The woman (J) said that she is unable to identify what city she is working in, she only said she was part of FLOWERS.COM, and she also said that she was UNABLE to send an email documenting the fact that she cancelled my membership and yet would issue the refund for the $29.99 fraudulent charge. She informed me that I could expect something -- the refund? -- in ten days or so. I have zero faith in this communication process or in the integrity of a business culture that takes money without consent but will not rectify their own errors with speed and ease nor sufficient documentation. I cannot get any written documentation from them saying that my PASSPORT membership is cancelled and that they understand that they should never run my visa again to implement an automatic renewal.
Worst possible business practices. When you become a subscribing or PASSPORT customer, your credit card number is kept on file but even after you have cancelled the subscription, someone or something "forgets" and runs a renewal under the rubric of, oh, "automatic." Bad business practices. I called my bank to cancel my current visa credit card number and get a new number issued. Cannot recommend ordering from Vital Choice or the conglomerate of Flowers.com

29/03/2023

Anna V

1.00/5.00

"ruined holiday"

ruined holiday! I always order from them for the past years and this was so awful, not same quality as before

07/01/2023

Albert Miller

1.00/5.00

"I signed up for the Celebrations 1800 Flower shipping service…"

I signed up for the Celebrations Service and paid the $19.99 to get shipping for one year. I just tried to place another order and was told they didn't have a record with 1800 Flowers (Celebrations Service). So I cancelled my order with Vital Choice. I had been a customer for several years when shipping was free. I am done with this company (Vital Choice). Just cancelled the order I was going to place.

21/12/2022

Mike Holley

1.00/5.00

"Not happy anymore-"

I've read the past reviews. It all makes sense with being acquired. The website became a mess, customer service is yucky. Have been a biiiig fan for years. Going elsewhere now

15/12/2022

WSS

1.00/5.00

"Very Disappointed"

As a previous customer I had no idea this company had changed. My 12 pieces of King salmon arrived a week late, thawed and a mess to dispose. Company offered to send me 6 pieces as a replacement, even though I paid for 12 pieces. The 6 pieces have yet to arrive. I won’t be ordering again…sad because the salmon was really tasty.

14/12/2022
Built for truth-seekers. We collect real reviews so you can find reliable businesses fast. Share your insights—help the next person out.
© 2025 - All rights reserved