Colonial Metals Group

Financial Operations and Advisory
badge Company profile claimed
82 reviews
Overall Rating
Customer Reviews about

Colonial Metals Group

Write a review about colonialmetalsgroup.com
Show Reviews

Just a plain warning

1.00/5.00

"This company flags any negative reviews…"

This company flags any negative reviews and tries to get them taken down. They flagged my previous review twice within three months. The first time, I had to provide documentation to prove my experience was real, which I did, and it was put back online within a few hours.

Last Wednesday, they flagged my review a second time. This time, they went after me for ‘harming their business’ by reporting them to the CFTC and suggesting others do the same if they have been scammed by one of these gold companies. The automated bot used by this website identified my post as “promotional materials” because it included contact information to help scam victims report a scam. So I edited it and this website put it back online.

The colonial metals group uses high-pressure tactics and misleading information to try and sell semi-numismatic coins at about double their actual value. They call and text repeatedly to the point of harassment and refuse to take ‘no’ for an answer. When their rating dropped down to about 4 stars, this website suddenly became flooded with what appear to be fake five-star reviews from unverified people, which all essentially say the same thing and name the same person. This is an extremely sophisticated scam. Don’t fall for it.

Edit: They flagged this review also, claiming defamation. This website found nothing wrong with my review and put it back online.

Edit: They have flagged 100% of the 1-star reviews. You can verify this by clicking on “how this company uses trustpilot” and then “flagging”. The site is slow to update, so the data does not yet include their third flag on me or the latest flag on someone else, which happened an hour ago.

Edit: They tried to get this post taken down for “defamation” when there was no defamatory content— this is the definition of trying to silence critical feedback.

23/03/2025

Philip K

5.00/5.00

"Customer service communicated clearly…"

Customer service communicated clearly and concisely .
Friendly, helpful and efficient.

21/03/2025

Jeffrey Hubbard

5.00/5.00

"I HIGHLY RECOMMEND Colonial Metals Group!"

My son & I have been considering investing in precious metals for some time now, & we were made aware of Colonial Metals Group while watching Stephen Gardner’s daily YouTube channel. I decided to reach out to Colonial Metals, & was pleasantly surprised by how professional the team there was. They made it effortless for my son and I to transition our Traditional IRA accounts from our existing bank over to Gold and Silver IRAs through Equity Trust. The team of Philip Matusov, Joe Shimko, & Tish Aldana lead us every step of the way, from Tish contacting our bank to help us start the transfer process, to Philip getting us in touch with Joe to help us choose the portfolio of precious metals that best suits our needs for investing in our future. Thanks so much guys for being so professional! For anyone thinking about protecting your future wealth, I highly recommend the team at Colonial Metals Group!

19/03/2025

alan rutchik

5.00/5.00

"Zach did an excellent job explaining…"

Zach did an excellent job explaining the process and keeping me informed. He was polite and knowledgeable and helped with educating me to make an informed decision

18/03/2025

A.H.

5.00/5.00

"Zach J"

Zach J. was very knowledgeable and helpful throughout the whole process. Would highly recommend anyone work with him in the future.

14/03/2025

Chuck White

5.00/5.00

"Had a great experience working with Zach"

Had a great experience working with Sr. Director Zach Jonik. Answered all my questions promptly and professionally. Checked in with me afterwards to make sure I was satisfied with the purchase. Would definitely recommend working with Colonial and Zach in particular

14/03/2025

William

5.00/5.00

"Had a great experience with Colonial…"

Had a great experience with Colonial Metals and, specifically Zach. Great service!!

14/03/2025

Maria Ramirez

5.00/5.00

"Great experience with this company"

I have a 401K account and was looking for alternatives since the market has been concerning.

I called Colonial and spoke to Blake Sawyer - he was very patient, knowledgeable and explained everything about current market conditions and the different options I had with gold and silver.

Everyone I spoke to at the office was kind and helpful, but Mr. Sawyer really stood out as someone that knows his stuff. Extremely happy and will be returning!

14/03/2025

kevin freeman

5.00/5.00

"Changing over to Colonial Metals."

Changing over to Colonial Metals so far, has been the best thing going for me lately.
I'm glad that I finally quit procrastinating. But. There's so much that I didn't understand about how it all works.
So far I have had the opportunity to talk with Alex, Tish and Candace.
Never have I felt misleading or dumb when I have asked many questions. They have eagerly took my questions and made sure I understood the answers.
With my other IRA accounts that I've had, getting information was a hassle. I don't feel that with the Colonial Metals and I'm super happy.
Now I have contacts name and numbers, and I feel like I have a team working for me.

Thanks so much.
Kevin.

14/03/2025

Gail Parker

5.00/5.00

"Colonial Metals Group"

I have been working with Colonial Metals Group for a few weeks. The individuals I have spoken with have been very professional and informative. They cannot recommend a product, but give several options and let me make up my own mind. I must commend Justin Davis, Tish Algana, and Candace Garcia for their assistance and information

13/03/2025
Built for truth-seekers. We collect real reviews so you can find reliable businesses fast. Share your insights—help the next person out.
© 2025 - All rights reserved