Coinfully

Hobbies & Crafts
badge Company profile claimed
159 reviews
Overall Rating
Customer Reviews about

Coinfully

Write a review about www.coinfully.com
Show Reviews

Butch

5.00/5.00

"First-time seller"

Being a first-time seller, my concerns were diminished with Matt's sincere approach. My research found that their approach to business was top notch and that my experience with them was the same. It was a pleasant experience.

01/02/2025

MR

3.00/5.00

"Customer service good, low ball offer though"

Quick and good customer service. They will low ball your offer. Shouldn't be this way, they should be more fair. My bad on not making a counter offer. I will take my next precious metal transaction elsewhere.

29/01/2025

Roxanne Russell

5.00/5.00

"Extremely helpful and knowledgeable…"

Extremely helpful and knowledgeable customer service reps. It's refreshing to know there really are reps out there who aren't perks. Thanks to all!
The process was quick and painless.

28/01/2025

Arthur L.

5.00/5.00

"Every step of this sale was handled…"

Every step of this sale was handled with total professionalism and efficiency. I would recommend Coinfully to anyone seeking to sell assets. My wife had reservations but she totally agrees with this choice after the transaction.

27/01/2025

T. Almaguer

5.00/5.00

"I appreciate the fair offers for my coins."

I was very happy with the service. I am satisfied with the amount offered for my coins. The process was easier and quicker than I expected. The check sent in email was cashed at my bank no questions asked. I was offered less money by other coin buyers. I will be using Coinfully again.

26/01/2025

Don

5.00/5.00

"I’m not a coin professional"

I’m not a coin professional, so I sought out those who are, and who are trustworthy and efficient. Selling online…I didn’t know what to expect. It sounded more convenient, but would I sacrifice the priority of trust and honesty? I worked mainly with Braden, and he and the company were very efficient — underscoring convenience — helpful, and professional. I felt the quotes were fair, although it’s difficult to quantify that for me, with coins. All in all, a good experience with a company I’d recommend.

24/01/2025

Steve Yonkof

4.00/5.00

"The only problem we had when dealing…"

The only problem we had when dealing with Coinfully was at the very end when we saw a discrepancy on the final appraisal. A large silver coin said that it was 1 pound of silver. The appraisal said that it was 8 oz. When we called Braden to question the discrepancy, he said that the pound was equal to 8 troy ounces. We can't find anything that says that a pound is only 8 troy ounces. If the coin is a troy pound, it is 12 troy ounces.

23/01/2025

Randall Deal

5.00/5.00

"Coinfully offered great prices for my…"

Coinfully offered great prices for my coins and made the process easy. They respond to questions quickly. Very impressed.

20/01/2025

Michael Novak

5.00/5.00

"Fair and prompt response with rapid payment. "

I had an old family coin collection and silver certificates to sell. In doing research I found prices to be across a broad range. I sent pictures of my collection to Matt and received a prompt, fair offer and fast payment.

I’ll gladly use Coinfully again.

20/12/2024

Lynn

5.00/5.00

"Wyatt"


Excellent service, Coinfully came to us, pleasant experience, immediate wire transfer payment for coin surrendered. Would recommend them to anybody in need of help disposing of their coin.

18/12/2024
Built for truth-seekers. We collect real reviews so you can find reliable businesses fast. Share your insights—help the next person out.
© 2025 - All rights reserved